Indiana Governor Eric Holcomb recently signed the “puppy mill bill” into law, a decision that has been met with strong opposition from the Humane Society of the United States. House Bill 1412, also known as the canine standard of care, aims to set regulations for commercial dog breeders and pet stores. However, it simultaneously overturns 21 local ordinances that prohibit the sale of dogs at retail pet stores, including those in St. Joseph County. Proponents argue the bill is a step towards eliminating puppy mills, but critics, including the Humane Society, warn that it might achieve the opposite effect.
Humane Society of the US strongly opposes ‘Puppy Mill Bill’
The legislation requires pet stores, animal care facilities, and rescues to register with the Board of Animal Health, a measure that at first glance appears to tighten regulations around the breeding and sale of puppies. Yet, the Humane Society of the U.S. has raised concerns that this bill inadvertently opens the door for puppy mills to operate under the guise of legitimacy — per ABC57. By invalidating local bans on the retail sale of puppies, critics argue that the bill removes an important layer of protection against inhumane breeding practices.
Samantha Chapman, the Indiana State Director for the Humane Society of the U.S., highlighted the challenges presented by House Bill 1412. “So, it really allows pet stores to operate business as usual,” Chapman stated, emphasizing that while the bill introduces some new standards, it fails to provide the necessary funding for their enforcement. This shortfall, she warns, could lead to increased burdens on local governments and animal shelters already grappling with overpopulation issues.
In light of these concerns, the Humane Society continues to advocate for adoption as the most humane and responsible option for those looking to welcome a pet into their home. “We really encourage people to go to their local shelters and rescues and adopt, to foster, to donate, volunteer, and to support our animal shelters,” Chapman said.
The controversial “puppy mill bill” will take effect this July.
